Researching the past … and finding memories
As a young child growing up on Chicago’s South Side in
the Hyde Park neighborhood, I wandered the land that once boasted the World’s
Columbian Exposition. My mother took me out in rowboats around Wooded Island,
and I learned to ice skate on the Midway, which still cuts a swath of green
through the city for more than a mile west from the lakeshore. My friends and I
made countless trips to the Museum of Science and Industry, the only exposition
building that survives. Much later I attended the University of Chicago, which
sits almost on the exposition grounds. That part of the city was “my” Chicago.
My love for that part of Chicago more recently became
entwined with a fascination for Bertha Honoré Palmer, frequently known as
Cissy. Raised to be a socially prominent and financially secure wife and
mother, she moved far beyond those roles to demonstrate her strength,
individuality, and civic concern. Where she could have spent her days, as the
saying goes, eating bonbons and reading frivolous novels, she became one of the
first to combine wealth with civic responsibility. Active in Chicago's Hull
House—a pioneer settlement house in an immigrant community—she also strove to
improve the lot of workingwomen and played a major role in the Woman's Club, an
organization devoted to civic concerns.
Her crowning achievement was as president of the board
of lady managers of the 1893 Columbian Exposition. Against the backdrop of an
artistic, intellectual, and showmanship event never rivaled in the twentieth
century, she managed to call international attention to the achievements of
women throughout the world while mediating between extremists among both her
sisters and the male population. No small feat, and the real Cissy Palmer has
my utmost admiration.
My interest in the Palmers and their era was intensified
when I read What the Lady Wants by
Reneé Rosen (New York: New American Library, 2014), a novel about Marshall
Field, the mecca of department stores in my childhood.
My own trip with the past began with a children’s book
on Cissy Palmer, one I researched and wrote. I knew of course about the luxury
of the Palmer House, the hotel Potter built and then built again after the
Great Fire of 1871. I began to dig deeper, beginning as always with obvious
sites on the internet, even Wikipedia which is a great place to start. This
internet study yielded among other gems several pictures of the house Potter
built for Cissy on the North Shore, now perhaps Chicago’s most fashionable
address but in Cissy’s day a sandy, weed-filled wasteland. The house was
extravagant and outrageous, and behind his back people referred to it as
Potter’s Folly.
But for me real research must finally come around to
books. For historical background, I am indebted to several sources. The Fair Women, by Jeanne Madeline
Weimann (Chicago: Academy Chicago, 1981), a lengthy, detailed, and superbly
researched account of women's role in the exposition, provided much of the meat
of this story. Also helpful for information about the exposition was Reid
Badger's The Great American Fair: The
World's Columbian Exposition and American Culture (Chicago: Nelson Hall,
1979) and Robert Muccigrosso's Celebrating
the New World: Chicago's Columbian Exposition of 1893 (Chicago: Ivan R.
Dee, 1993). For general history of Chicago, I consulted City of the Century: The Epic of Chicago and the Making of America, by
Donald L. Miller (Simon & Schuster, 1996), City of Big Shoulders: A History of Chicago, by Robert G. Spinney
(Northern Illinois University Press, 2000), Chicago,
Crossroads of American Enterprise, by Dorsha B. Hayes (New York: Julian
Messner, Inc., 1944), and Chicago, A
Pictorial History by Herman Kogan and Lloyd Wendt (New York: E. P. Dutton
and Company, Inc., 1958). Most recently I read The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair
that Changed America, by Erik Larson (New York: Crown, 2003).
My primary source for details about Cissy Palmer's life
was Ishbel Ross' Silhouette in Diamonds:
The Life of Mrs. Potter Palmer (Harper & Brothers, 1960), but Ross, a
well-known biographer, must not be blamed for the direction Mrs. Palmer's life
takes in these pages of fiction.
And finally some points of the story come with my own
love for and familiarity with the South Side of Chicago. Though it is now more
than fifty years since I lived there, I still carry Chicago in my heart.
How wonderful of you to share your research with us!! I know I want to know more about this well-researched book!!
Blurb:
Born to a society and a life of privilege, Bertha Honoré married Potter Palmer, a wealthy entrepreneur who called her Cissy. Neither dreamed the direction the other’s life would take. He built the Palmer House Hotel, still famed today, and become one of the major robber barons of the city, giving generously to causes of which he approved. She put philanthropy into deeds, going into shanty neighborhoods, inviting factory girls to her home, working at Jane Addams’ settlement Hull House, supporting women’s causes.
Born to a society and a life of privilege, Bertha Honoré married Potter Palmer, a wealthy entrepreneur who called her Cissy. Neither dreamed the direction the other’s life would take. He built the Palmer House Hotel, still famed today, and become one of the major robber barons of the city, giving generously to causes of which he approved. She put philanthropy into deeds, going into shanty neighborhoods, inviting factory girls to her home, working at Jane Addams’ settlement Hull House, supporting women’s causes.
It was a time of tremendous change and conflict in Chicago as the city struggled to put its swamp-water beginnings behind it and become a leading urban center. A time of the Great Fire of 1871, the Haymarket Riots, and the triumph of the Columbian Exposition. Potter and Cissy handled these events in diverse ways. Fascinating characters people these pages along with Potter and Cissy—Carter Harrison, frequent mayor of the city; Harry Collins, determined to be a loser; Henry Honoré, torn between loyalties to the South and North; Daniel Burnham, architect of the new Chicago—and many others.
The Gilded Cage is a fictional exploration of the lives of these people and of the Gilded Age in Chicago history.
Yes, this sounds just like the kind of novel I enjoy reading. I have this on my TBR list and hope to get to read it soon.
Here is an excerpt from the book:
Excerpt:
Excerpt:
"You upset about Little Egypt?"
Carter Harrison edged cautiously into Cissy Palmer's office. He found her
sitting at her desk with a murderous expression on her face, and, for a long
moment, he thought she wasn't going to speak to him. She simply stared, anger
in her eyes.
"I said, are you upset about Little
Egypt?"
"Why not?" she replied, her
voice deadly quiet. "I'm upset about everything else. You might as well
add Little Egypt to it."
He began to fumble in words. "Well,
I mean, the commissioners’ statement . . . ."
"Have you read this?" She
thrust a newspaper toward him.
The offending passage had been underlined
in red, no doubt by Cissy herself. "The building," Carter read,
"is practically a white elephant." The statement was from Secretary
Hovey of the commission, and the article went on to quote Secretary Hovey's
opinion that women artists of the highest rank had refused to have anything to
do with the Woman's Building. "I think we should turn the building into a
large kindergarten," he concluded.
"Do you wonder I'm not upset over
continued performances at Little Egypt?" she asked as he raised his eyes
from the article. "They don't care that we exist, let alone that an
exhibit on the Midway is offensive to us." Then, after a moment, she said,
"I suspect Phoebe Couzins . . . or one of her cohorts . . . got to him. I
will never be free of that woman!”
"And St. Gaudens' 'Diana' on our
building—now I'm hearing that women are offended by its so-called immodesty.
Good heavens, Carter, we get a renowned sculptor like St. Gaudens practically
to contribute a magnificent work of art, and women quibble because of its
drapery!" She threw her hands in the air in impatience.
He could, he knew, placate her, point out
the success of the building, the prestigious works it housed, the crowds who
had poured through it in the first week. But she would counter that Ellen
Richards had kept her Rumsford Kitchen out of the building, putting it in the
liberal arts building. Throughout the fair, women were exhibiting in other categories,
so that Cissy's dream—a building where visitors could see the produce of women
all in one place—was shattered. And she would counter, rightfully so, that no
matter what she did, she was criticized.
"Get your hat," he said quietly
but with determination.
"Pardon me?" She had expected
him to argue against her anger, persuade her of the importance of her work and
the building, cajole her out of her mood. She had not expected to be ordered
about.
"Get your hat," he repeated,
"and your purse, unless you feel comfortable leaving it here."
"Where are we going?"
The first hint of a smile crossed his
face. "Never mind. Just do as I say." Then, as an afterthought,
"It's past noon. Are you hungry?"
She'd been too angry to think about food,
but now that he asked, she admitted, "Maybe. A little."
"Good," he said, holding out
his arm, "I wasn't planning to feed you one of those fancy twelve-course
meals you're used to."
With her arm safely tucked in his—he put
his big hand over her smaller one, so that she could not gracefully escape when
she saw where they were headed—Carter Harrison escorted Cissy Palmer from the
Woman's Building. Once outside, he turned directly west, toward the Midway.
She hesitated. "Carter . . . ."
"I won't listen," he said.
"I'll drag you if I have to."
She looked to see a smile on his face,
but he seemed deadly earnest, staring straight ahead.
They paraded past most of the
concessions—the Algerian Village, the ring where John L. Corbett challenged any
and all comers to a boxing match, even the infamous Little Egypt. Cissy, now
feeling incapable of rebelling, kept her eyes straight ahead.
They stopped in front of the Ferris
wheel.
"Two," Harrison said to the
ticket-taker, who smiled and said, "No tickets for you, Mr. Harrison. You
and your friend go right ahead on. Boss' orders."
Cissy tried to pull her hand away.
"No. I won't set foot in that thing."
Looking at her, Carter saw the slightest
sign of fear, an emotion that Cissy Palmer would never publicly admit.
"It's perfectly safe, Cissy. Thousands
of people have ridden it already."
Something—her fear, perhaps?—loosened her
tongue. "That only means it's about to crash," she said, her anxiety
totally uncharacteristic of the controlled woman he knew. "I've heard
people talking . . . predicting a horrible accident from this
monstrosity."
"Nonsense," he said. "They
had a problem at first with the brakes—not strong enough to stop it once it got
going—but they've got air-powered brakes now, and they've not had one problem.
Come on," and he walked determinedly into the cage, which sat at ground
level.
Cissy's choices were to accompany him or
create a scene, and she was too much the lady to do the latter, no matter how
horrendous the situation.
She was astonished at the size of the
cage they entered. Made of wood and iron, it had swivel seats to hold forty
people—Cissy did a quick rough count—and along one end was a counter where food
and drink could be purchased.
Carter saw that she was seated in a chair
near the counter—he did not exactly shove her, but his touch was firm as he
helped her into a chair. "Stay here," he said.
She nodded.
He returned in a moment with two plates
of cold chicken, fresh fruit, and glasses of champagne.
She ate more hungrily than she had
expected, and she felt the tension ease away from her as she sipped her
champagne. But as the wheel began to move again and the car lurched with
movement, she grabbed the sides of her chair convulsively.
Carter stared at her. "Cissy? You're
afraid of height, aren't you?"
"I don’t know," she managed to
say. "I've never been higher than the third floor of our house."
"You lived on top of the Palmer
House," he reminded her.
"Oh, but that was inside,
different," she said.
He reached out and took one of her hands
in his. "You'll be fine," he said, "and you'll love the
view."
At first she wouldn't look, but as the
car climbed higher—with frequent stops while other cars, below, were loaded
with passengers—she began to steal glimpses straight ahead. Then she would look
to one side and the other, and finally she stood to get a better view.
"Better sit back down," he
said. "It's safer."
"But look, you can almost see our
house."
He followed her pointing finger and
thought he saw the absurd turrets of the Palmer mansion, miles away on North
Lakeshore Drive. Between them and the mansion lay the city, spread out like a
relief map. They began to point out this place and that to each
other—"Look, there's State Street" and "Isn't that Prairie
Avenue?"—until they were giggling like schoolchildren.
To the east, the lake glistened and
shimmered. "I can see clear to Michigan," she told Carter, who smiled
and shaded his eyes as though to see farther.
Cissy grew silent, and he watched her
surreptitiously. But the look on her face was one of rapture as she gazed out
at her city and her lake, spread out before her in a way that, previously, only
birds had seen them.
"Carter," she said, turning to
him with such enthusiasm that she, without thinking, took his hand in hers,
"It's the most wonderful thing I've ever seen! And to think I'd have
missed it if you hadn't bullied me into going."
"I didn't bully you," he
protested, but he never moved his hand.
When their cage began its descent, Cissy
complained, "I can't see as far." And when it reached ground, she sat
unmovable for a moment.
"You want to go again?" he
asked.
"No," she said, laughing,
"not now. But later, yes."
"You liked it?" He beamed with
pleasure.
"Yes, Carter, I loved it." Her
mood, she realized, was lighter than it had been since before the controversy
over who would ride with the Duchess of Veruga had put her in a frenzy. But
even as she spoke, she remembered that Potter had said he was going to ride the
wheel days ago . . . and she had never asked if he did, nor with whom.
Judy Alter's Bio:
An
award-winning novelist, Judy Alter is the author of several fictional
biographies of women of the American West. In The Gilded Cage she has
turned her attention to the late nineteenth century in her home town, Chicago,
to tell the story of the lives of Potter and Cissy Palmer, a high society
couple with differing views on philanthropy and workers’ right. She is also the
author of six books in the Kelly O’Connell Mysteries series. With the 2014
publication of The Perfect Coed, she
introduced the Oak Grove Mysteries.
Her work has been recognized with
awards from the Western Writers of America, the Texas Institute of Letters, and
the National Cowboy Museum and Hall of Fame. She has been honored with the Owen
Wister Award for Lifetime Achievement by WWA and inducted into the Texas
Literary Hall of Fame and the WWA Hall of Fame. http://judyalter.com/
Here are her links:
Blog URL: http://www.judys-stew.blogspot.com
Facebook URL: https://www.facebook.com/judy.alter
Skype: juju1938
Buy link for The Gilded Cage
http://www.amazon.com/Gilded-Cage-Judy-Alter/dp/0996013121/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1460738028&sr=8-1&keywords=the+gilded+cage+alter
Judy has a blog tour planned for The Gilded Cage starting on May 23rd. Go to her blog to find out the details.
Thank you for being my guest today and I am looking forward to our radio spot. Judy Alter is giving away a free book to the lucky commenter who is picked. So leave a comment to be in the running for a free book!!!
Judy has a blog tour planned for The Gilded Cage starting on May 23rd. Go to her blog to find out the details.
Thank you for being my guest today and I am looking forward to our radio spot. Judy Alter is giving away a free book to the lucky commenter who is picked. So leave a comment to be in the running for a free book!!!
Until the next time Judy Alter will be my guest for August on Red River Radio Tales from the Pages along with my friend Nina Haberli, so mark your calendars now for Thursday, August 25 at 4PM EST. Don't worry I will remind you before then if you don't remember.
My guest on Red River Radio Tales from the Pages for May on Thursday, May 26th will be Amy Leigh McCorkle, who will be bringing her cast for the film, Letters to Daniel. We will be talking about the award winning screenplay and her journey so far with this very unusual project. In addition we will be discussing her Kickstarter for this. She is trying to raise money for her movie and once you read about this very brave and determined woman you might want to contribute to help her make this film a reality. For anyone who has bipolar disease or knows someone with bipolar disease, this program will also be discussing Amy's experience with her own bipolar disease. The screenplay explores how she has learned to live with it.
How fascinating. Chicago is my favorite city. I grew up "down state" so trips to the big city were very special for me. Sounds like a book I'd enjoy. Thank you for sharing your research. Best wishes with your writing projects!
ReplyDeleteThis book looks like a fun read!
ReplyDeleteThanks to both of you. The book was fun to write--I got lost in the world of the Columbian Exposition and loved every minute of it.
ReplyDeleteSounds like a wonderful book. I love it when the author's love of a city or location shines through. It gives the work such a wonderful ambiance and layering. I'll be sure to try and listen on Thursday. Always a pleasure to visit with Barbara via BlogTalk Radio.
ReplyDeleteI hope you win it Nancy! Yes, try.to listen to Amy on my show. She has the dates all set and I hope she raises the money by then!!
Delete